Cookie monster ice cream is the kind of dessert that instantly sparks joy. With its bold blue color and cookie-loaded goodness, this frozen treat brings childhood memories rushing back—whether you grew up watching Sesame Street or just love anything sweet and colorful. It’s creamy, crunchy, sweet, and playful—all in one bite.
What sets cookie monster ice cream apart is its simplicity. No need for an ice cream maker, complicated custards, or churning every half hour. This no-churn recipe uses sweetened condensed milk and whipped heavy cream to create a rich, scoopable texture. The best part? It’s bursting with chunks of Oreos and Chips Ahoy, making every spoonful a cookie lover’s dream.
This recipe isn’t just easy—it’s insanely fun to make. You can dye it that classic vibrant blue with gel food coloring (don’t worry, it’s optional), and customize it with your favorite cookies or add-ins. Whether you’re hosting a birthday bash or simply craving a late-night dessert, cookie monster ice cream fits the bill.
We’ll walk you through everything: what flavor it really is, how to make it from scratch, how to store it, and even where you might find cookie monster ice cream in your favorite scoop shops.
Don’t miss our ninja creami recipes to pair with this ice cream for the ultimate dessert party combo.
Let’s get started with a look at where this whimsical frozen treat came from and what makes it so addictively good.
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
What Is Cookie Monster Ice Cream and Why Is It Blue?
The Origin and Rise of Cookie Monster Ice Cream
The concept of cookie monster ice cream was born from the whimsical world of childhood and pop culture—specifically inspired by the beloved blue character from Sesame Street. Cookie Monster, known for his endless love of cookies and chaotic energy, became the perfect mascot for an over-the-top dessert bursting with cookie chunks.
Though the exact origin of this flavor isn’t pinned to one brand, it quickly became a staple at gourmet scoop shops, fun food trucks, and viral recipe blogs. The appeal? It’s a visual standout with a bold blue base and loaded with cookie pieces—usually Oreos, chocolate chip cookies, or both. Over time, families and creators began adapting the flavor at home using no-churn methods, making it more accessible and wildly popular on platforms like Pinterest, Instagram, and TikTok.
In short, this ice cream isn’t just a treat—it’s a trend.
Print
Cookie Monster Ice Cream
- Total Time: 6h 10 mins
Description
After months of testing and perfecting ice cream recipes in the kitchen , I’m excited to share my Cookie Monster Ice Cream recipe. This fun, family favorite is bright blue and loaded with cookies! With my simple instructions, you can make it at home—no ice cream maker or prior experience required!
Ingredients
- 2 cups (473ml) heavy whipping cream, 1 pint
- 1 Tbsp vanilla extract
- ½ tsp Blue gel food coloring, I used AmeriColor brand
- 14 oz (396g) can sweetened condensed milk
- 20 Oreos, chopped
- 15 Chips Ahoy Cookies, chopped
Instructions
- In a stand mixer or using a handheld mixer, beat the heavy whipping cream, vanilla extract and blue gel food coloring until stiff peaks form.(2 cups (473ml) heavy whipping cream,1 Tbsp vanilla extract,1/2 tsp Blue gel food coloring)
- Add in the sweetened condensed milk, beating on low until combined. Add additional blue food coloring to get your desired shade of blue. (14 oz (396g) can sweetened condensed milk
- Fold in the chopped oreos and chopped cookies. Transfer the ice cream to a loaf pan, 8 inch cake pan, or similar container. Add additional oreo and cookie pieces on top. Cover the pan with plastic wrap or a lid and freeze for at least 6 hours, overnight is preferred. (20 Oreos,15 Chips Ahoy Cookies)
Notes
- I recommend using gel food coloring, not liquid food coloring. The gel food coloring may temporarily stain your tongue when eating the ice cream. You can always make it without the food coloring if you prefer—it’s not quite as fun, but it’s just as delicious!
- Store Cookie Monster Ice Cream tightly covered in the pan for up to two weeks.
- Prep Time: 10 mins
- Cook Time: 6 h
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 10
Why Is Cookie Monster Ice Cream Blue?
The blue hue is one of the most iconic features of cookie monster ice cream, and it’s not just for looks. It mimics the color of the Cookie Monster himself, adding a playful, nostalgic twist that instantly grabs attention.
But what makes it blue? The answer lies in blue gel food coloring—a concentrated form of dye that allows vibrant color without altering the texture of the ice cream. Unlike liquid food coloring, which adds excess moisture and can water down your dessert, gel food coloring keeps the base creamy and stable. A small amount goes a long way, so you only need half a teaspoon or less to reach that signature bold shade.
Still, the color is optional. Skip it, and you’ll have a delicious vanilla-cookie base with all the same crunch and creaminess, just minus the vibrant flair.
If you’re wondering whether this blue goodness will stain your tongue—yep, temporarily. But honestly, that’s half the fun.
The Flavor Profile: More Than Just Cookies and Cream
Despite its playful look, the taste of cookie monster ice cream is surprisingly balanced. Think of it as an upgraded cookies-and-cream flavor: a creamy vanilla base layered with contrasting textures from soft whipped cream, sweetened condensed milk, and cookie crumbles.
The Oreos bring that familiar chocolatey crunch, while Chips Ahoy cookies (or your favorite chocolate chip brand) add buttery sweetness. It’s a flavor that satisfies both kids and adults—sweet but not cloying, smooth yet chunky, and irresistibly fun.
Looking for inspiration? Try Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream to pair with your next ice cream night.
Key Ingredients in Cookie Monster Ice Cream
The Creamy Foundation: Why Heavy Whipping Cream Is a Must
To create the rich, dreamy base of cookie monster ice cream, the most essential ingredient is heavy whipping cream. This isn’t the time to swap in milk or half-and-half—those simply won’t do the job. Heavy cream whips into stiff peaks, creating a stable, airy structure that mimics the churned texture of traditional ice cream without needing a machine.
The key here is fat. Whipping cream contains enough fat to trap air as it’s beaten, forming soft, fluffy peaks that give the final dessert its ultra-smooth, scoopable consistency. Without this, you’d end up with a frozen block rather than luscious, creamy ice cream.
So don’t skimp. Always choose high-quality, full-fat heavy whipping cream for the best results.
Sweetened Condensed Milk: The Sugar Substitute That Changes the Game
Instead of using regular granulated sugar—which can lead to grainy textures in frozen desserts—this recipe relies on sweetened condensed milk. Why? It’s smooth, already dissolved, and adds both sweetness and body to the mixture.
When combined with whipped cream, sweetened condensed milk turns the base into a thick, rich foundation that freezes beautifully. It also eliminates the need for heating or stirring a custard, which means less time at the stove and more time enjoying your ice cream.
It’s a key ingredient that gives cookie monster ice cream its signature creamy sweetness without any of the fuss.
Oreo and Chips Ahoy: The Cookie Combo That Delivers Crunch and Flavor
No version of cookie monster ice cream is complete without its namesake cookies. The classic combo? Crushed Oreos and chopped Chips Ahoy.
The dark chocolatey crunch of Oreo cookies balances perfectly with the chewy, buttery flavor of Chips Ahoy. You get texture in every bite, from soft cookie pieces to crumbly bits. For an extra punch, toss in a few cookie chunks on top before freezing—it adds visual appeal and that extra crunch factor everyone loves.
Want to get creative? Swap in your favorite homemade chocolate chip cookies, or try mini versions for a cute twist.
Why Gel Food Coloring Works Best
That iconic blue color isn’t just for show—it’s part of the fun. But not all food coloring is created equal. For the bold, vibrant look without ruining the texture of your mix, gel food coloring is the way to go.
Gel coloring is highly concentrated, so a tiny amount goes a long way. Unlike liquid food coloring, it doesn’t water down the base or interfere with freezing. For a striking effect, start with just ½ teaspoon of royal blue gel and add more if needed.
Some brands to try: AmeriColor, Chefmaster, and Wilton—all available online or in craft stores.
If you’re worried about stained tongues, you’re not alone. It might happen—but it’s part of the Cookie Monster charm.
How to Make Cookie Monster Ice Cream at Home (No Churn Method)
Step-by-Step: Make It in Under 10 Minutes (Plus Freeze Time)
You don’t need a fancy machine or culinary degree to whip up cookie monster ice cream at home. This recipe is beginner-friendly, fast, and foolproof. Best of all? It takes just 10 minutes to prep and only a handful of ingredients.
Here’s how to make your own batch:
- Whip the cream – Pour 2 cups of cold heavy whipping cream into a large bowl. Add 1 tablespoon vanilla extract and ½ teaspoon blue gel food coloring. Use a hand mixer or stand mixer to whip until stiff peaks form. This creates the rich, airy base that mimics churned ice cream.
- Add condensed milk – Gently fold in a 14-ounce can of sweetened condensed milk. This brings smooth sweetness and helps everything hold together when frozen. You can add more food coloring here if you want a brighter blue.
- Fold in the cookies – Roughly chop 20 Oreos and 15 Chips Ahoy cookies. Fold about ¾ of them into the mixture. Save the rest to sprinkle on top later for extra crunch and visual appeal.
- Freeze it – Transfer everything into a loaf pan or airtight container. Top with extra cookies, then cover and freeze for at least 6 hours—overnight is even better for the perfect scoop.
Quick Tips for Best Results
- Use cold ingredients – Starting cold helps the whipped cream stiffen quickly.
- Avoid overmixing – Gently fold ingredients to keep the whipped texture intact.
- Try mini cookies – For added fun, use mini Oreos or bite-sized chocolate chip cookies.
With this no-churn recipe, your cookie monster ice cream will come out thick, creamy, and packed with texture—and without any icy chunks or weird separation. Whether it’s for a party or just a treat-yourself night, this version delivers maximum flavor with minimal effort.
Customizing Your Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Switch Up the Cookies for Flavor Variety
One of the best parts about cookie monster ice cream is how easy it is to make it your own. While the classic combo includes Oreos and Chips Ahoy, feel free to experiment with different cookies to create your signature version.
Try using:
- Fudge-striped cookies for a chocolatey swirl
- Peanut butter cookies for a nutty twist
- Homemade chocolate chip cookies for a softer bite
- Gluten-free cookies to make it allergen-friendly
Keep your cookie chunks around ½ inch for the best texture—big enough to stand out, but not so large they take over.
Add-Ins That Take It to the Next Level
Want to go beyond cookies? Here are a few fun additions that pair perfectly with this bold blue treat:
- Mini M&M’s for a colorful crunch
- Sprinkles for a party vibe
- Swirls of Nutella or cookie butter for added richness
- Crushed pretzels for a sweet-and-salty finish
Fold these in along with or instead of cookies, depending on your mood.
Flavor Variations to Try
If you want to enhance the base flavor, there are simple ways to do it without messing up the texture.
Try:
- A touch of almond or mint extract for a subtle shift
- Chocolate syrup mixed into the condensed milk
- Coconut flakes folded in for tropical flair
Whatever changes you make, don’t mess with the heavy cream or condensed milk. Those are key to keeping your cookie monster ice cream smooth and scoopable without an ice cream maker.
Dye-Free Options for a Natural Look
If the bright blue isn’t your thing, skip the food coloring. You’ll still get that creamy vanilla flavor with cookie chunks—just in a more neutral tone. It won’t be quite as playful, but it’s equally delicious.
Customizing cookie monster ice cream is half the fun. Whether you’re tailoring it for dietary needs, themed parties, or personal taste, it’s one recipe that invites creativity.
Serving Suggestions and Presentation Ideas
Fun Ways to Serve Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Cookie monster ice cream is more than just a frozen treat—it’s a showstopper. Its vibrant blue color and cookie-stuffed texture make it ideal for parties, holidays, or just adding fun to an ordinary day. Presentation matters, and a few creative ideas can turn your scoop into a memorable experience.
Try serving it:
- In waffle cones dipped in chocolate and sprinkles
- In small mason jars for a grab-and-go party dessert
- With a drizzle of chocolate or caramel syrup on top
- Scooped into cookie bowls for double the cookie fun
Want to go extra? Top it with whipped cream, mini cookies, or a maraschino cherry for a retro sundae look.
Perfect for Parties and Kids’ Events
The bold blue color makes this ice cream an instant favorite at children’s parties—especially Sesame Street–themed events. Use themed cups or decorate your serving table with Cookie Monster cutouts for added fun. Kids love the surprise of cookie pieces in every bite, and it’s easy to serve in big batches.
You can also turn cookie monster ice cream into:
- Ice cream sandwiches using soft chocolate chip cookies
- Milkshakes by blending with a little milk
- Ice cream cakes layered with brownies or graham crackers
Adult-Friendly Serving Ideas
Even grown-ups can’t resist this colorful dessert. Try pairing it with a slice of warm brownie or sandwich it between two fresh-baked cookies. For a sophisticated twist, serve it in chilled martini glasses with crushed cookies on the rim.
Whether you’re planning a party or just want to enjoy a scoop after dinner, cookie monster ice cream offers endless ways to impress. Its flavor, color, and creamy texture do most of the work—you just bring the fun.
Storage Tips and How Long It Lasts
How to Store Cookie Monster Ice Cream the Right Way
After all the effort of whipping up your delicious cookie monster ice cream, proper storage is key to keeping it creamy and flavorful. Since it’s a no-churn recipe, it freezes differently than store-bought options—but don’t worry, it’s easy to manage.
First, transfer the ice cream to a freezer-safe airtight container. A loaf pan works well, but make sure to cover it tightly with plastic wrap or a fitted lid to prevent freezer burn. If using plastic wrap, press it directly onto the surface of the ice cream to protect the texture.
How Long Does It Last?
When stored correctly, cookie monster ice cream will stay fresh in the freezer for up to two weeks. After that, it may still be safe to eat but could develop an icy texture or lose some of its creaminess.
Avoid frequent thawing and refreezing. Instead, scoop what you need and return it to the freezer immediately. Using a warm spoon helps to glide through easily without over-melting the batch.
With just a little care, your homemade batch will stay scoop-ready and satisfying for days, making it a go-to dessert any time.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cookie Monster Ice Cream
What flavor is the Cookie Monster ice cream?
Cookie monster ice cream typically has a vanilla base, but the real flavor comes from the crushed cookies inside. Most versions use a mix of Oreos and chocolate chip cookies like Chips Ahoy, which gives the ice cream a cookies-and-cream taste with extra crunch and sweetness.
Does Dairy Queen have Cookie Monster ice cream?
No, Dairy Queen doesn’t offer cookie monster ice cream as a standard menu item. However, some seasonal Blizzards or regional creations may include blue-colored or cookie-packed flavors that come close. It’s best to check with your local DQ for current offerings.
Why is Cookie Monster ice cream blue?
The vivid blue hue is inspired by Sesame Street’s Cookie Monster character. To achieve this signature look, most recipes use blue gel food coloring. It adds bold color without altering the texture. While the color itself doesn’t add flavor, it makes the ice cream playful and fun—especially for kids.
Does Baskin Robbins sell Cookie Monster ice cream?
Sometimes. Baskin Robbins has released cookie monster-themed flavors as part of limited-time promotions. These are not always available, so if you spot it, grab a scoop while you can. Your best bet? Make it at home for whenever the craving strikes.
Conclusion: Make Cookie Monster Ice Cream Your New Favorite Treat
Whether you’re whipping it up for a party, a weekend treat, or just to see that signature blue smile, cookie monster ice cream is the perfect no-churn dessert to wow kids and adults alike. With its vibrant color, creamy texture, and cookie-loaded flavor, it hits all the right notes of fun and flavor.
This recipe is simple, flexible, and freezer-friendly—meaning you can make it ahead and customize it however you like. Skip the ice cream aisle and create a batch right at home with ingredients you probably already have.
Discover more Cookie Monster ice cream recipe ideas on Grandyrecipes’ Pinterest, and get the latest updates, tips, and recipes by following Grandyrecipes on Facebook.